On Saturday 17th March 2018 the Centre for Intra-Muslim Studies held a discussion on ‘Tawassul (Intermediation) in the light of the Islamic Tenet of the Sole Authority of God‘ presented by Dr Khuram Bashir from Green Lane Mosque for the Sunni point of view, followed by a presentation from the Shia point of view by Shaykh Arif Abdulhussain.
Dr Khurram started his presentation on Tawhid with Ibn Taymiyyah’s views on Tawassul and Shaf’aa from his book Qa’ida al Jalila fi al-Tawassul wal Wasila, of which, the main view is that every act of worship is for God. He also went on to acknowledge the different opinions amongst the Sunni schools of thought on this matter. He then touched on the types of Tawhid (al Ubudiyya, Rububiyya, Uluhiyya. al-Asma wal-Sifaat) and that it should be implemented in all elements of life.
This was followed by Shaykh Arif’s presentation during which he explored whether asking others conflicts with Tawhid of worship. He also looked at whether it is permissible to ask from a dead person or not. He examined Tawassul from the Quran and Sunna to determine whether asking other than God (independent or dependent of God) is in contradiction to Tawhid, and whether asking God through a means isin contradiction with Tawhid
The presentations were followed by a Q&A session, with various questions directed to both the Shia and Sunni scholars. Mufti Farooq also offered alternative views amongst the Ahlul-Sunna regarding Tawassul,and provided the justifications for each viewpoint. The Chair, Dr Mohammad Khalid concluded that:
- The principles of Tawhid are agreed upon by both schools, as is the permissibility of asking a living person for help with the view that God has ultimate power.
- Asking anyone dead or alive, independent of God, is not permissible.
- The permissibility of asking God through an intermediary is a point of dispute among the scholars as there are varied opinions even within both schools of thought.
To view more images from the discussion, please click here.
To watch the full discussion, please click on the links below.